more than I can conceive. Loans of money may certainly chance, now and then, to find their way into the pockets of projectors as well as of other men: but when this happens, it must be through incautiousness, or friendship, or the expectation of some collateral benefit, and not through any idea of the advantageousness of the transaction, in the light of a pecuniary bargain. I should not expect to see it alleged, that there is any thing, that should render the number of well-grounded projects, in comparison of the illgrounded, less in time future, than it has been in time past. I am sure at least that I know of no reasons why it should be so, though I know of some reasons, which I shall beg leave to submit to you by and by, which appear to me me pretty good ones, why the advantage should be on the side of futurity. But, unless the stock of well-grounded projects is already spent, and the whole stock of ill-grounded projects that ever were possible, are to be looked for exclusively in the time to come, the censure you have passed on projectors, measuring still the extent of it by that of the operation of the laws in the defence of which it is employed, looks. as far backward as forward: it condemns as rash and ill-grounded, all those projects, by which our species have been successively advanced from that state in which acorns were their food, and raw hides their cloathing, to the state in which it stands at present for think, Sir, let me beg of you, whether whatever is now the routine of trade was not, at its commencement, 1 ment, project? whether whatever is now establishment, was not, at one time, innovation? How it is that the tribe of wellgrounded projects, and of prudent projectors (if by this time I may have your leave for applying this epithet to some at least among the projectors of time past), have managed to struggle through the obstacles which the laws in question have been holding in their way, it is neither easy to know, nor necessary to inquire. Manifest enough, I think, it must be by this time, that difficulties, and those not inconsiderable ones, those laws must have been holding up, in the way of projects of all sorts, of improvement (if I may say so) in every line, so long as they have had existence: reasonable therefore it must be to conclude, that, had it not been for these discouragements, projects H jects of all sorts, well-grounded and successful ones, as well as others, would have been more numerous than they have been: and that accordingly, on the other hand, as soon, if ever, as these discouragements shall be removed, projects of all sorts, and among the rest, well-grounded and successful ones, will be more numerous than they would otherwise have been: in short, that, as, without these discouragements, the progress of mankind in the career of prosperity, would have been greater than it has been under them in time past; so, were they to be removed, it would be at least proportionably greater in time future. That I had done you no injustice, in assigning to your idea of projectors so great a latitude, and that the unfavourable opinion you have professed to entertain of them is not confined to the 66 the above passage, might be made, I think, pretty apparent, if it be material, by another passage in the tenth chapter of your first book*. "The "establishment of any new manufacture, of any new branch of com"merce, or of any new practice in "agriculture," all these you comprehend by name under the list of “ pro'jects:" of every one of them you observe, that "it is a speculation from "which the projector promises himself "extraordinary profits. These pro"fits (you add) are sometimes very "great, and sometimes, more frequently perhaps, they are quite otherwise: but "in general they bear no regular pro"portion to those of other old trades "in the neighbourhood. If the project succeeds, they are commonly * Edit. 1784, 8vo .p. 177. << at |