網頁圖片
PDF
ePub 版

the owner, he may state this fact, and perfect his lien without naming an owner; and also that, if in good faith he gives the name of a reputed owner, he will not lose his lien if it afterwards appears that some other person was the owner.

Section 308.-PRIORITY OF MATERIAL-MAN'S CLAIM OVER MORTGAGE.-The lien of a materialman for lumber furnished for a dwelling will take precedence of a mortgage on the land executed immediately upon a conveyance thereof, but after the time when the materials were commenced to be furnished, notwithstanding the mortgage was given for the purchase price of the land.

Section 309.- DWELLING-HOUSE-LAND SUBJECT TO LIEN.-Only so much of the land around a dwelling-house is subject to lien as may be necessary for the convenient use and occupation of the house. So, where a house was situated on a forty-acre tract, the Supreme Court has said that the whole tract was not subject to the lien. The statute does not contemplate anything of that kind. It means exactly what it says-a sufficient space around the dwelling convenient use and occupation. It does not contemplate

for its

that sufficient land around the dwelling-house to support the while living there be set apart. Neither the pro

Owner

ductiveness or non-productiveness of the soil, nor the profit derived from the cultivation of the land, is a material element

to be

considered in determining the amount of land to be

set apart with the dwelling-house. The statute simply allows the dwelling-house and a quantity of land around it sufficient for its convenient use, as the subject of a lien.

Section 310.-ELEVATOR PART OF BUILDING.Where the original plans for a large building provided for an elevator, and the contract for the construction of the elevator was let when contracts for other work were let, the elevator was a substantial part of the building, and the

building

was not completed, so that the limitations for filing

mechanics' liens would run, until it was finished. An elevator

was called for by the original plans and specifications. A contract was let for its construction at the same time that other contracts were let. It was attached to the building, and formed an integral part of it. The fact that the building might have been used without it, and that it was a convenience merely, is immaterial. Conceding an elevator to be a mere convenience-still conveniences are a material part of the building, when provided for by the plans and specifications; and, so provided for, the building is not completed until the demands of the plans and specifications in this regard have been satisfied.

Section 311.-MATERIALS MUST BE EXPRESSLY FURNISHED FOR STRUCTURE CHARGED WITH LIEN. In order to enforce the lien of a material-man against a building or structure, the materials must not only have been used in the construction of the building, but they must have been, by the express terms of the contract, furnished for the particular building on which the lien is claimed.

Section 312. ASSIGNMENT OF MECHANIC'S LIEN. A mechanic's lien can be assigned, after the claim of lien has been filed for record, but not before. Before the claim of lien has been filed for record, the right to the lien is a mere personal privilege, which the laborer, mechanic, or material-man may exercise or not, as he sees fit; hence it is not the subject of assignment. But after the claim of lien has been filed for record, it can be assigned, and the assignee will have all the rights of the original holder of the lien.

Section 313.-IF BUILDING IS DESTROYED BY FIRE, NO LIEN CAN AFTERWARDS BE FILED. -Where a building in course of construction is destroyed by fire, without any fault of the owner, before any mechanic's lien has been filed thereon, the party who furnished materials for the building, or who performed labor upon it, can have no lien upon the land upon which the building was being

.

constructed. The benefit conferred upon the owner, by placing the labor and materials in his building, is the true consideration in law for conferring the right of lien upon the parties furnishing such labor and materials. It cannot be said. that this consideration exists, where the building is destroyed before completion and before delivery to the owner. In such case, the owner has not derived and can never derive any benefit from the labor and materials furnished. (Decided by the Supreme Court of California in the case of Humboldt Lumber Mill Company vs. Edward Crisp, which decision is printed in Volume 29, California Decisions, page 629.)

Section 314.-LIEN FOR WORK DONE BY ORDER OF HEALTH OFFICER.-A law passed in 1909 provides as follows:

"Any health officer or governing board of any city, town. or sanitary district, having served written notice upon the owner or reputed owner of real estate upon which there is a dwelling house, and such owner or reputed owner, after thirty days, having refused, neglected or failed to connect such dwelling house, together with all toilets, sinks, and other plumbing therein, properly vented, and in a sanitary manner, with the adjoining street sewer, may construct the same at a reasonable cost, and the person doing said work at the request of such health officer or governing board has a lien upon said real estate for his work done and materials furnished."

Act of the Legislature, approved April 19, 1909.

Section 315.- MINER'S LIEN MUST BE UPON
WHOLE CLAIM.-A mechanic's lien cannot be

THE

claimed upon part of a structure, or upon a structure which is part of a larger structure, or upon part of an entire prop

erty.

Therefore, it has been held by the Supreme Court of

California that a claim of lien for materials furnished for the construction of a mill, tramway, boarding-house, or reduction

works

mining

a mining claim, should be against the claim, and not against the specific structure

upon

upon the mine. One contributing labor or materials to a structure which is an appurtenance to a mine, or which, when constructed, is to form part of it, must be held to have anticipated its future use, and cannot claim a lien upon the structure alone. And the procedures provided for acquiring liens upon structures are not, in all respects, applicable to those claiming liens upon mining claims. They cannot all date back to the commencement of the work. On a mine the work is always going on, may have commenced before the laborers were born, and may continue indefinitely. There is no special thirty days, therefore, within which mining lienors must record their notices and claims of lien. The labor cannot generally be said to have contributed to the creation of the property, or added to its value; on the contrary, it may diminish its value-perhaps render it valueless. The Code does not seem to have provided for all the cases which may arise in regard to liens upon mining claims. We can only follow the procedure so far as applicable. For that purpose, the mining claim must stand in the place of the "structure" as the property to be charged with the lien. It is the property which should be described in the notice and claim of lien. One who has built a chimney in a house, or a porch, or a door-step, has helped to build a structure; but he cannot acquire a lien upon these specific structures, and by detached sales destroy the value of the claims depending upon liens upon the whole house. A structure may be a part of another larger structure, and in reference to it constitute but a part of a structure. In such cases it is well settled the lien must cover the entire structure. The mining lien, if it exists at all, extends to the whole claim. Strictly speaking, of course, a mining claim cannot be constructed, altered, or repaired. The intention of the lawmakers seems to have been to give a lien upon the whole claim, for labor performed on and for materials furnished for and used in any structure, on or in the mining claim. The lien given by the statute is upon the mining claim as a whole, and not upon the separate pieces of work done in its repairs. A claim of lien for material furnished, to be used in a building upon a mining claim,

should be against the mining claim, and not against the specific structure upon the mine.

Section 316. MINING GROUND PATENTED LAND.-A lien for work and labor may be taken upon mining ground owned by a patentee of the United States. The words "mining claim" in the statute include "mining ground" and all "mines," whether the title is perfect or not. But the lien will not extend to adjacent land which is not mineral in its character. The words "mining claim," as used in the law, have no reference to the different stages in the acquisition of the Government title. It includes all mines where no patent has been issued, as in the case of a mining claim in its strict sense, and also where the patent has issued.

Section 317.-PERSONAL PROPERTY LIENS.

Every person who, while lawfully in possession of an article of personal property renders any service to the owner thereof, by labor or skill, employed for the protection, improvement, safe keeping, or carriage thereof, has a special lien thereon, dependent on possession, for the compensation, if any, which is due to him from the owner for such service; a person who makes, alters, or repairs any article of personal property, at the request of the owner, or legal possessor of the property, has a lien on the same for his reasonable charges for the balance due for such work done and materials furnished, and may retain possession of the same until the charges are paid; and livery or boarding or feed stable proprietors, and persons pasturing horses or stock, have a lien, dependent on possession, for their compensation in caring for, boarding, feeding, or pasturing such horses or stock; and laundry proprietors and persons conducting a laundry business, have a general lien, dependent on possession, upon all personal property in their hands belonging to a customer, for the balance due them from such customer for laundry work; and veterinary proprietors and veterinary surgeons, shall have a lien, dependent on possession, for their compensation in caring for, boarding, feeding, and medical treatment of animals; and

« 上一頁繼續 »